No Self, No Mind, No Consciousness

The start

Recently, I was talking to a friend about consciousness, and as it turns out, I don’t believe in consciousness in any traditional way. For similar reasons, I also don’t believe in the existence of a mind or a self. This clearly isn’t a typical view, and so he asked if I could give some clarification. What follows is that clarification (with a few climbing references given along the way).

The short version

I don’t believe in an inner someone who has experiences and makes decisions, and I don’t think “mind” or “consciousness” names a separate thing on top of what the organism does. What exists is information processing, modeling, and behavior guidance. Part of that processing is a model of the organism itself, and that model produces the strong impression of being one unified someone with a private inner life. From this point of view, there is no person “Carrot” who likes to rock climb and writes for theDIHEDRAL.

I am not saying nothing is going on inside us. I am saying that the words self, mind, and consciousness make the picture more complicated than the evidence supports.

A note on wording: I use “I” and similar words as shorthand for this organism and its self-model, because ordinary language offers no better option. Words like “believe” work the same way, as convenient labels and not as claims about inner states.

What I say instead

Each everyday word points at something measurable, except the felt inner quality, which I take to be the organism’s model of its own states.

Everyday wordWhat I think it refers toHow it shows up in measurement
SelfA model the organism builds of itself as one agent with a point of view, used for planning and for keeping behavior coherentSelf-recognition, body-ownership effects (the rubber hand illusion), autobiographical memory
MindA label for the whole bundle of information-processing capacitiesTests of memory, attention, learning, and decision-making
Consciousness as wakefulnessLevel of arousalSleep and wake states, EEG, responsiveness
Consciousness as awarenessInformation that is available for report and flexible controlReport versus performance in masking, blindsight, and attention studies
Consciousness as felt inner qualityNo separate thing. The organism represents some of its own states as private and feltNothing beyond the reports and behavior it produces
“I decided”The outcome of competing processes, often explained after the factConfabulation and choice-blindness studies

Two Pictures I reject

Both pictures put a someone inside the system, and neither holds up.

The Cartesian theater. The intuitive picture is that everything the organism processes gets shown on an inner stage, where an audience experiences it. But the organism has no single place where everything comes together. Processing runs in parallel across many systems, with no moment of arrival. If there is no stage, there is no audience. There is no witness to the view from the top of a mountain.

The homunculus. The related picture is a little driver inside the head who watches, decides, and steers. It is part of folk psychology and hard to shake, because it matches how things feel. It fails for two reasons:

  • It explains nothing. Whatever the driver does still needs explaining, which calls for another driver inside that one, and so on without end.
  • It cannot be measured. No observation tells it apart from the processes that already account for behavior. Defending it means filling an explanatory gap with an unobservable agent, which is the pattern of a god-of-the-gaps argument.

My view avoids both. Behavior is guided by many interacting processes, with no central place and no controller. The feeling of a controller is something the self-model produces.

Why drop the words

The words add a layer to the model without adding anything I can measure or predict with.

  • Parsimony. Everything the words are used to explain is already covered by information processing, modeling, and behavior guidance. An extra inner entity needs a reason to be added, and I haven’t found one.
  • Measurability. The measurable parts of “consciousness” (arousal, attention, reportability) already belong to the processing vocabulary. What is left over, a felt quality beyond the reports, cannot be observed or tested on its own.
  • Track record. Other sciences dropped folk categories such as a life force and caloric fluid as they matured. Everyday mental vocabulary looks like the same kind of thing: useful shorthand, not a verified part of the machinery.
  • Introspection is unreliable. People confabulate reasons for their choices, and in choice-blindness studies they defend choices they never made. The sense of direct access to an inner life is weak evidence that the inner life is what it seems.

What is left

What remains is an organism that processes information, builds models, and uses them to guide behavior.

  • Processing. Many systems work in parallel on perception, memory, planning, and action.
  • Modeling. The organism builds models of the world and of itself. At any one moment, one of them represents the whole organism as a single agent with a point of view.
  • Behavior guidance. These models help the organism predict, plan, and coordinate, and systems that model themselves this way have an advantage.

The self-model also explains why the picture feels so convincing. It cannot present itself as a model, so it feels like direct reality: there seems to be someone here, and it seems like something to be them. That feeling is a product of the processing. It sure seems like I am the one taking a fall on a whipper in the Red Rocks, but seeming and reality are two very different things.

What I am unsure about

I hold this view as the best account I have found, not as settled truth. Some skepticism remains, and better evidence or a better explanation could change my mind.

I am also open to some form of idealism, because I don’t think materialism has a decisive argument against it. This current position however, does not depend on idealism, and nothing above leans on it.

Leaning on others

The account laid out above isn’t based on any of my own original work. It is an account that is influenced heavily from the work of others, especially Daniel Dennett, Keith Frankish, Thomas Metzinger, and The Churchlands.

Information Processing Model referred to as Carrot

4 Replies to “No Self, No Mind, No Consciousness”

  1. sunyamar's avatar

    This is a lot to digest as a life long (7 scores & 6 yrs.) faith believer. I suppose “believer” is the tell all. Thank you for sharing this fact base info article for us folk wanting knowledge as well as fun!

    Looking forward to the groups food choices for holidays!!

  2. Martha Kennedy's avatar

    I’ve (huh?) been thinking about this stuff too. I have no way to explain it really, so I don’t expect this to make sense. My thinking started with a video a guy in my stepson’s philosophy group posted about freewill. “The Illusion of Freewill,” was, I think, the title. It was — to me — so bogus. It actually illustrated something REAL but the scientist(s) behind it insisted on “finding” the conclusion they’d started with? The scientist was Libet; the video is — I think — pretty old. But his insistence that there are two “I’s” — the involuntary spasm that comes from a small charge (electric impulse) to the brain and the “decision” to move one’s finger? Brain and mind. Two things. Just no. And then I thought of Descartes and the strange things he insisted upon that were not math.

    I agree with you that language makes it possible for us to talk to each other (and possibly ourselves?) and our dependence on it, our need for language to understand others, creates a kind of dependence on it when it comes to understanding ourselves? We need to conceptualize ourselves?

    Not too long ago I got to have a talk with a horse. Those conversations do not rely on language at all. Horse sees Martha. He’s seen her many times before. They’ve stood there thinking at each other often over the years, but too far away. Martha’s close to the fence for the first time. Horse strolls over to Martha and lays his head over her shoulder. There’s no conceptualization; there is a moment when the distinction between beings vanishes. I am not “I”; horse is not “horse.” Outside of time and consciousness.

    As for climbing? In my experience climbing comes close to that as does running on a trail.

    1. thedihedral's avatar

      Martha, what the!!! A horse came over to you and rested its head on your shoulder. I don’t think I could have moved a muscle in hopes that the moment lasts as long as possible. I’m sure that moment with live with you for a very very long time. Good for you, that is amazing! In terms of bad science and philosophy, I always try to remind my students that good philosophy and science for that matter does not try to argue to a conclusion. It starts with a question and is lead by reason. It sounds like the people in the video were going about that all wrong! My guess is that they never even had a horse rest a head on their shoulder!

      1. Martha Kennedy's avatar

        Horses are not married to their idea of themselves. I don’t know how many times I’ve been out there with my dogs, scared and sad about something, and I just stood beside the horse’ fence and “told” them. Not “what” or “why” but just the feelings of the thing. Physiologically horses have the ability to match our heart rates — they literally “feel” us. It’s incredible. I like communicating with horses. And when that horse rested his nose on my shoulder? I just wrapped my arms around his neck. He sighed. They’ve wanted to meet me and I them for a long time. Another horse? There’s a guy who rides out at the Refuge sometimes — he’s a retired Veterinarian. The second time he and his horse (Sem for semen) rode over to me, Sem — who’s big — dropped his nose to the top of my head — I’m only 4’11” — and snuffled. Horse for “You’re OK by me.” His human is one of the greatest philosophers I’ve known. That day? There were deer flies all over. We were chatting and suddenly the man said, “Gotta’ go. Too many flies.” Seriously. That’s profound wisdom. They took off across the open country. I think the whole idea of language, self, consciousness vanishes — or diminishes — when you spend time with intelligent non-verbal creatures or put yourself somewhere (a rock face?) where our holy sacred precious human ego is an obstacle. Here’s Sem and his person escaping the flies

        https://martha-kennedy.blog/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/beautiful-horse-816.jpg

Leave a Reply